Best Itch Cream for Bug Bites in 2024

Best Itch Cream for Bug Bites in 2024

Like it or not (and you surely don't), bug bites are as much a part of summer as ice cream trucks. The itchiness and discomfort can drive anyone up the wall. That's why finding a good bug bite relief cream is pretty much a summer survival necessity. This article explains why bites itch and goes deep into finding the best itch cream for bug bites.

Why Do Bug Bites Itch?

Why does a tiny bug cause such big itchiness? Fleas, bedbugs, mosquitos, and others all bring about that almost intolerable sensation. When they bite, your body reacts to their saliva. It's an unwanted gift that keeps on giving – itching and swelling, and sometimes even causing a more severe allergic reaction.

As tempting as it is, scratching is a no-go. It can lead to more irritation and infections. So, keep the fingernails away and look for the best itch cream for bug bites instead.

Top 8 Bug Bite Itch Creams

The itch relief creams, patches, and other remedies, such as mosquito patches for adults and mosquito patches for kids, are all there to help you deal with the unpleasant sensation. Let's look at the best of the best.

1. BuzzPatch Magic Patch Itch Patches

BuzzPatch Magic Patch Itch Patches

With BuzzPatch Magic Patch, you can put a patch on the bug bite and forget about it. Peel, stick, and the itchiness will be gone in almost no time.

This itch patch is big for natural remedy fans, ditching the chemicals and going with natural ingredients that are safe for adults and kids. They're especially handy for the little ones who seem to be a bug's favorite target. Who knew fighting off bug bite itch could feel a bit like playing with mosquito stickers?

2. Gold Bond Medicated Pain & Itch Relief Cream With Lidocaine

Here's a heavyweight in the anti-bug itch cream arena: Gold Bond Medicated Pain & Itch Relief Cream with Lidocaine. What makes it special is lidocaine, an ingredient that numbs the itch and pain. 

Gold Bond is a well-known name, and this best mosquito itch cream doesn't stray from the usual quality. It's not just about numbing; it's also about soothing. The cream has a nice, non-greasy feel, so you won't be left feeling like you've just wrestled with a tub of butter.

3. Cortizone-10 Maximum Strength Anti-Itch Creme

Cortizone-10 Maximum Strength Anti-Itch Creme bug bite itch cream is also worth reaching for when a bug bite turns into an itchy nightmare. As the name suggests, the formula includes hydrocortisone, a known agent that has a calming effect on inflammation and waves goodbye to the maddening itch.

What's great about this cream is its maximum strength formula that brings out the big guns. But despite the strength, it's still gentle enough for daily use, which is a plus if you're someone who tends to be a bug magnet. Also, the cream has a smooth feel to it, not too greasy or sticky.

4. Bug Bite Thing

Here's something different – the Bug Bite Thing. This isn't a typical cream or lotion. It's a gadget that sucks out the poisons that make bug bites so annoying. 

The Bug Bite Thing is pretty straightforward. You place it over the bite, pull up on the handles, and it gets to work.

The device is chemical-free. No creams, no lotions, just suction power. It's handy for those with sensitive skin that doesn't play nice with topical treatments.

It's also reusable, which is a big thumbs up for the environment and the wallet. Wash it and it's ready for the next time.

5. Benadryl Extra Strength Itch Relief Stick

Then there's the Benadryl Extra Strength Itch Relief Stick. This little stick can fit in your bag or pocket until you need to soothe some bug-bite unpleasantries. Benadryl, a name many know, especially when allergies rear their ugly heads, brings its A-game with this stick. It uses an antihistamine to tackle the itch and a pain reliever to soothe the sting.

The stick form means no messy creams or spills. Just pop the cap, roll it on, and you're good to go. It's perfect for quick applications, especially when out and about, like hiking or at a picnic.

6. Badger Itch Relief Balm

Let's a look at natural bug bite itching cream remedies with the Badger Itch Relief Balm. This is a balm to soothe your bug bite woes with purely natural ingredients. Badger's blend of organic remedies, like calming calendula and cooling menthol, mixed with a little essential oils is a recipe that your skin will love, especially if it's sensitive or not too keen on synthetic materials.

The balm's texture is richer and thicker than an average cream, giving a sense of deep nourishment to the skin. And despite its richness, it doesn't leave you feeling greasy.

Best yet, the balm isn't solely for bug bites. It can be soothing for all sorts of minor skin irritations. And its compact size makes it perfect for travel – a little goes a long way.

7. Bite Away Insect Sting & Itch Relief Stick

The Bite Away Insect Sting & Itch Relief Stick is not a cream, not a lotion, but a stick that uses concentrated heat to calm bug bite itchiness. Think of it as a mini heat wave that targets just the spot that's bothering you. You hold it against the bite, press a button, and it delivers a quick burst of heat.

As you can imagine, it's completely chemical-free. No ingredients list to check, and no worries about allergies or skin reactions. It's just heat. But it acts extremely quickly, in mere seconds.

8. Sarna Original Anti-Itch Lotion

Last but not least is the Sarna Original Anti-Itch Lotion. This bug bites lotion is a classic bug bite relief cream – it's been around for a while, and for good reason. Sarna's lotion is a combination of cooling menthol and camphor, working together to cool down your skin and calm the itch.

Once you apply it, you can feel it getting to work almost instantly. And despite its effectiveness, it's gentle enough for daily use, which is a big plus if you're dealing with ongoing skin issues.

The lotion itself has a nice consistency – not too thick, not too runny. It spreads easily and absorbs quickly, so you're not left feeling sticky or greasy.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Itch Cream

Since not all itch creams are created equal, don't just grab the first cream you see. Here's what to consider:


The ingredients matter a lot. Here are some contents to look for:

  • Hydrocortisone – Reduces inflammation and calms that maddening itch.
  • Calamine – It makes for a comforting, cooling feeling your skin needs when it's irritated.
  • Diphenhydramine – This antihistamine makes your body relax the itch response.

And for those leaning towards Mother Nature's remedies:

  • Aloe Vera – It's cooling, soothing, and a little hydrating.
  • Tea Tree Oil – It smells good and has antiseptic properties to keep things clean and calm.

Chemical vs. Natural

On one hand, there are chemical creams – fast, powerful, and ready to tackle serious itches. On the other, natural remedies – gentler, with fewer side effects, and a friend to sensitive skin.

When to choose which?

If you're dealing with an intolerable itch, a chemical cream might be a better bet. But if your skin is more sensitive, natural remedies might be the way to go. Dermatologists often lean towards milder, natural products for long-term use or for those with sensitive skin.

Safety and Skin Sensitivity

Your skin is a delicate barrier. If it's on the sensitive side, you should only let the gentlest, most high-quality remedies touch it. Always conduct a patch test with new products. If it has a list of chemicals longer than your grocery list, maybe give it a pass. And remember, just because it's natural doesn't mean it's a free pass – natural ingredients can be allergens too.

Absorption and Residue

Fast-absorbing formulas are the way to go. They soak into your skin and do the trick without leaving a greasy mess behind. Plus, they won't carry over to your clothes or sheets.

How to Apply Bug Bite Treatments Effectively

Applying itch relief creams might seem straightforward, but there's an art to it for maximum effectiveness. First, clean the area gently. Then, take a tiny amount of bug bite cream – a little often goes a long way – and apply it to the bite. Spread it evenly, but don't go overboard.

Avoid open wounds or broken skin when applying the cream, and steer clear of the eyes. If the bite is near sensitive areas, like your eyes, it's best to consult a doctor first.

While waiting for the cream to kick in, a cool compress can be a great temporary relief that calms the itch and reduces swelling. Just a clean cloth and some cool water are enough.

Soothe Your Skin: Finding Your Ideal Itch Relief

Whether you're a fan of the fast-acting chemical creams or lean towards the gentler touch of natural remedies, there's something for everyone. There are even reusable gadgets that are completely chemical-free but relieve the itch just as effectively.

Don't forget about the innovative options like the BuzzPatch Magic Patch. The itch patch is a fun, natural, and mess-free way to keep itchy bug bites at bay. Perfect for both kids and adults, these bug bite patches are the hassle-free summer companions you've always wanted.


What is the best cream for itchy bug bites?

It depends on your skin type and the severity of the bites, but creams with hydrocortisone or calamine often work well.

What is the best thing to take for itchy bug bites?

Topical creams are great, but for more severe reactions, oral antihistamines can also help.

Is hydrocortisone good for insect bites?

Hydrocortisone is effective in reducing inflammation and itching from insect bites.

What's the best anti itch cream for bed bug bites?

Creams with stronger active ingredients like hydrocortisone or diphenhydramine are often better for the persistent itch of bed bug bites.

Back to The Natural Patch Co. Blog